Judgments - Blacklisting
M/S Health Secure India Pvt.Ltd. Versus The State Of Madhya Pradesh
Naman Seva Samiti Versus Central Wool Development Board Ministry Of Textile
State of Odisha & Ors. VERSUS M/s Panda Infra project Limited
Pratham National Security vs. Union of India & Others
Bombay Intelligence Security (India) Ltd. Vs. State of M.P. and others
Abha Chaudhary Vs. The State of Bihar
Star Build Max Pvt. Limited, Vs. The State of Bihar
Espan Infrastructure(I) Limited Earlier known as Espan Infrastructure Ltd. Vs. The State of Bihar
M/s.Shanti Construction Vs. M/s.Aavantika Gas Ltd & Ors.
Law laid down - 1. Constitution of India – Article 12 – Whether Avantika Gas Ltd (AGL) is an instrumentality/authority and amenable to writ jurisdiction of High Court. As per averments of reply of AGL - it is a public company limited - a joint venture of two PSUs namely GAIL and HPCL - government does not hold share in AGL “directly” - government has no pervasive/deep control in the “day to day affairs” of AGLgovernment has no direct share holding Full Judgment
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. & others Versus M/s Krishna Gas Agency
Law laid down - A show cause notice to constitute the valid basis of a blacklisting order, such notice must spell out clearly, or its contents be such that it can be clearly inferred therefrom, that there is intention on the part of the issuer of the notice to blacklist the noticee. Full Judgment
M/S EXCEL SPORTS INTERNATIONAL VERSUS NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ANR
Health Care Medical Devices Pvt. Ltd. Vs. MP Public Health Services Corp. Ltd., & Anr
Law laid down - Blacklisting and debarment-it has drastic impact on the contractor - Thus, such a drastic action can be taken by following “due process”. Issuance of a notice by which contractor can gather the nature of allegations and intended action to be taken is must. The order of blacklisting/debarment cannot be passed unless such an action is proposed in the show cause notice or it can be clearly inferred by reading of notice that such an action was proposed. The Full Judgment